08 January 2015

Review: Almost Famous Women by Megan Mayhew Bergman


I have a small problem: I will read a book, like it, and intend to review it.  "Intend" being the operative word in this scenario. Then, three months later when the book is actually published, I've forgotten most of what I want to say about it.  Also, I read the book on a digital ARC to begin with, and anything that I highlighted disappeared along with the entire text on the publication date, so that's just one more layer of obfuscation that I'm dealing with in trying to write a review.

I could resolve to review books I read in a more timely manner, I suppose, but I know myself well enough to know that it will never happen.  Not unless by some miracle I got hired for big bucks so I could quit my day job in order to write really vague and occasionally unprofessional reviews, and that ain't likely to happen.

Yup, that's me all right.
Thus, I give you an incoherent and rather hazy review of a book that I enjoyed when I read it in October: Almost Famous Women, a collection of short stories from Megan Mayhew Bergman. She takes as her jumping-off point the lives of real historical women who had their moment in the spotlight, but for whom their fame, if it ever came, was fleeting.  A few of these women I'd had actually heard of before: Beryl Markham, the aviator; Butterfly McQueen, the actress who played Prissy in the film Gone With the Wind; and Dolly Wilde, niece of Oscar Wilde, whose name became familiar to me in 2014 as the nom de plume of the protagonist in Caitlin Moran's novel, How to Build a Girl.   Oh, and I'd heard of Shirley Jackson, the author who is most known for her short story, "The Lottery," but I'd never read her before.

The other women comprising the characters in these stories were just as interesting: a set of Siamese twins from the 1930s; a daredevil boat-driving woman; Edna St. Vincent Millay's sister, Norma; Lord Byron's illegitimate daughter, Allegra, who was relegated to a convent; the artist Romaine Brooks; a troupe of integrated musicans traveling through the Jim Crow South; and in a chillingly poignant 2-page story, the nameless women liberated by Allied forces in the Bergen-Belson camp.

Bergman jumps around in her point of view with each story, sometimes narrating in a first person or close third person of the woman in question, sometimes through the eyes of their lovers, or from somebody entirely on the periphery of the woman's story. For the chapter on Shirley Jackson, she actually does a retelling of "The Lottery," and sacrilegious though it may sound, for my money, I prefer Bergman's. (I went back and read the original after I read the updated version, and to be fair, once the reader reaches the climax in one story, it's inevitably anti-climactic in the other.)

Each story is a snapshot, and an intriguing one at that, highlighting moments ranging from the quiet to the sublime. I also love that each chapter, with the exception of the ones on the Bergen-Belson women and Shirley Jackson, open with an portrait of the subject, and in most cases, literal snapshots. As with any story collection, the stories here are occasionally uneven, and some of them certainly resonated more with me than others, but this is a strong collection. I loved the concept behind it and would recommend it to any reader who enjoys historical fiction, literary fiction, short stories, or biographies of interesting ladies. So, pretty much everybody, in other words.

NB: This book was published by Scriber on 6 January 2015, and I read a digital advance reading copy that was provided upon my request by the publisher. It qualifies for my "diversify your life" listing because many of the characters are women of color OR fall under the LGBT spectrum.

11 comments:

  1. "Not unless by some miracle I got hired for big bucks so I could quit my dab job in order to write really vague and occasionally unprofessional reviews" - that is the dream

    I am impressed by how much you remembered about the book without having it there to refer to.

    I do like the idea of shifted points of view...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, don't be *too* impressed. The book was published on Tuesday, so I opened the finished copy at the store and made notes about the main character in each chapter. I probably only would have remembered more than 4-5 of them otherwise!

      Delete
    2. You could have totally played it off like you just remembered all that.

      Delete
  2. This sounds really interesting - what a good premise for a collection of short stories! Thanks for the review :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. THANK you for reminding me about this. I loved Birds of a Lesser Paradise SO MUCH...and I think I bought it at a library sale last year so I could reread it (HA!).

    So anyway, because of you I made it only 11 days into the new year before breaking my resolution and adding to my library hold list. *sigh*

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I get that you don't want to break resolutions so early and whatnot, but how can using the library be a *bad* thing? Just expand your resolutions to include using the library when something really great is published and you're golden.

      Delete
  4. Oh do you mean DAISY AND VIOLET HILTON, about whom the musical Side Show is based? (you totally do; there are no other conjoined twins from that time period who were famous enough ladies) Damn I love that musical.

    I WILL READ THIS, EMS.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I...guess I mean Daisy and Violet? I don't remember their names, much to my shame. But sure, let's go with that. I don't know the musical Side Show, so perhaps I need to check it out!

      Delete
    2. The lyrics are hooooorrible, but the music is awesome. So what I am saying is -- yes. Yes go do that.

      Delete
  5. I'm so excited for this one. But I fear that when I really like reading this one, I will have to go back and read her first story collection. My tbr list is weeping....

    ReplyDelete

Please, sir, may I have some more? (Comments, that is!)